Showing posts with label Braithwaite. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Braithwaite. Show all posts

Monday, March 19, 2012

Baxter & Brainwaith 23 and Boyd & Hargiatti

When Facebook first made profiles public, I remember that I saw the default option was to go along with it and that I deliberately changed it.  I didn't like the idea of being found by just whoever under my real name - I'd hung out in a lot of other locales where just about anyone could see my profile, but those profiles were anonymous, not connected to the real me outside giving out my first name and general location.  (I challenge you to track me down with the keywords 'Hanna' and 'Pacific Northwest'.)  I have never put my phone number on Facebook, or my address.  Since then, I hadn't thought much about what other users were seeing, but what companies and apps were seeing was definitely on my mind, at least for the last year or so.  After reading Boyd & Hargiatti, I was compelled to go on Facebook and check my settings out to see how secure they were.  The process of privatizing my information was just as complex as Boyd, Hargiatti, and Nancy Baym complained, and I was surprised to see that somehow much of my info had ended up accessible to 'friends of friends' instead of just 'friends,' which was what I thought I'd initially specified.  I was also surprised to see my email listed as accessible to friends.  The only things 'public' were my likes (in music, TV, etc.)  It took a little less than an hour to make sure that all of this information (likes, profile, etc.) was accessible only to friends, listing my email as accessible only to myself (I have no idea what the point of this feature is, but it worked for me removing it from others' view since I couldn't figure out how to delete it entirely), and cleaning up my friends list to only people whose names I could actually recognize at first glance (something I'd been meaning to do for a while, although there were not many people in this category since it has been years since I friended anyone who asked and was associated with my high school).  Finally, I confronted apps.  In high school, I used Facebook to kill time a lot more than I do now, leaving me with about 140 mostly unused applications that could access my information.  Much to my relief, I found a button allowing me to 'delete all apps' instantaneously, and did so.  This was when I was greeted with a surprise: a message asking if I wanted to opt out entirely of apps having access to my info.  I quickly did so, but what surprised me about it was that the message also assured me that, even if I opted out of giving apps my data, I could actually continue to use them, if I was okay with the fact that games, etc. couldn't remember me or save my information.  What struck me about this is that previous to then, any time I clicked a new app, I was completely unable to proceed to it until I had given it access to all of my private information.  So yes, Facebook has the resources to make one's profile pretty completely private... but why is it that I had to find out about how from a source that was not Facebook and take an entire hour to do it?  And why do I still not feel like my information is completely secure... and since I don't, why don't I just delete my Facebook?

The short answer is "because my sister asked me not to."  And now that I've gone over my settings with a fine-tooth comb, the idea of staying on doesn't bug me.  But the idea of her staying on without having done so bothers me a lot... she is a constant Facebooker, who recently told me she takes pride in the fact that the last several posts on my wall are from her.  I know she uses the site intelligently, more or less... she doesn't put anything on Facebook that she doesn't want her peers as a general group to see, and when she has more private information to convey, she chooses a different channel (email, Skype, phone) to convey it.  On the blog she is sharing with her best friend to tell stories of their adventures in London with others, she is even more careful.  The blog is meant for their mutual friends, myself included, but it's accessible to anyone with a Blogger account.  Despite claims that youth don't care about privacy, the Boyd & Hargiatti study shows they do, and I think that's true.  But it's easy to assume, when you're told, that just pressing a button to change your privacy settings to 'custom' takes care of it.  You've changed something that is related to your privacy that does, in fact, make your profile more private... but it might not do everything you want or expect it to, and it might give you a false sense of security.  Which is worrisome.  Information disclosure as described in Baxter & Brainwaithe is a pretty deliberate thing, especially in sensitive matters.  You don't tell everything to everyone, and the act of telling is very deliberate... one chooses how to tell secrets, and to whom, very carefully.  You don't want people to overhear, and depending on your skill with and understanding of technology, people well may when you're disclosing information on Facebook.  Sure, you can use Facebook carefully, and many people do, but some users are ignorant.  And when it takes me at least an hour to fix my privacy settings and I'm one of the people who thinks about this, and has been thinking about this for at least a couple years, it is not those users' fault.

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Baym Ch. 3 and Baxter & Braithwaite Ch. 29

Chapter three of Baym's book, on communication in digital spaces, and chapter 29 of Baxter & Braithwaite, on Social Information Processing Theory, are the first readings of this class that I have immediately and unquestioningly found myself agreeing with, almost completely.  I am a long time 'netizen', in the words of some digital communication scholars.  I first started exploring the Internet when I was about 9 or 10, back in elementary school.  Over time, my patterns of use, and amount of use, have waxed and waned depending on a variety of independent factors.  At this point, I am less engrossed in exclusively-online social situations than I have been before, but I still spend a lot more time on the internet than most of my peers.  The exact number of hours per day (at least ones that are not devoted to online schoolwork) is hard to determine and varies from day to day, but usually during school it's around 2-3 hours per day on weekdays, about 5 on weekends, and a truly incredible amount during vacations when I have no work - sometimes as many as 8 or 10.  I read webcomics, I watch media, I read blogs, I post on Facebook, I read and look at fan works (both art and fiction) for the media I'm interested in, and many more things I am not quite sure how to describe.  What I don't do very often right now is post on online forums, but I used to, mostly creative play-by-post role playing (a type of communal story-creating where each person controls one character and their interactions drive the plot).  But I used to, and it was usually with people I didn't know in person in the least, people in Florida, New England, the UK, Texas - people years older than me, people from different social classes than me, people I never would have met without the Internet.  And though I had friends 'irl' as well, the relationships I had with my writing partners online were many of them very close.  We shared photos of ourselves, personal information, and at times had serious, genuine emotional discourse.  After a while, I ceased having time for such activity, and I haven't contacted them much since then, but I know that the group I was part of stays in online contact.  They have each other's phone numbers, they consult each other in crisis, and they've even met in person a few times.  Their relationship, conducted via the Internet across borders of state and even country, was as close as those of any friends who might have met in person.  They trusted each other.  So I can say without question that I believe in the power of digital communication to bring people together in a genuine way, rather than pushing them apart - I've witnessed it, and even experienced it, myself.

The other point that intrigued me, showing up mostly in Baym, was the idea of reproducing verbal/nonverbal cues through an exclusively textual setting by playing with font, effect, color, html, and even grammar, as exemplified in lolcats, among other memes.  Baym suggests that this activity may help create immediacy in SMS and IM conversations, rather than being merely a symptom of sloth or lack of grammatical knowledge on the part of the communicators.  Initially when I started using the Internet, texting, etc., I was obsessed in my pursuit of correct grammar and spelling in all my posts and interactions online.  However, as time has passed, I've found myself more and more slipping on this - not using periods, capitalization, sometimes abbreviating words arbitrarily, etc.  I use emoticons to express feelings when my actual facial expression can't, and I use italics, bold, and caps lock to indicate tone of voice where there is none.  The use of these tricks to create artificial immediacy and flow, and to display personality, is something I really enjoy doing.  Outside of chat, I've even seen it done in webcomics.  One comic I read in particular uses these tricks to great effect.  The main characters spend much of the plot physically separate from one another, communicating solely through instant messaging chat clients.  To tell them apart, in long conversations shown solely through chat logs, each character types using a distinct style and color - some with punctuation, some without, some with capitalization, some without, some always typing in caps, etc.  The individual style in which each character types not only distinguishes them from one another, it also conveys distinct personality styles and vocal qualities where there are none (for example, a character with a lisp who replaces his 's's with '2's when he types).  The idea that these quirks can be used to express immediacy and personality, rather than laziness, is something I'd been trying to put words to for some time, and reading these Baym and B&B chapters was very helpful for me in this way.